Strategy & Positioning 14 guests | 39 insights

Strategic Product Positioning

Define the context that makes your product's unique value obvious and undeniable

Includes our free 8-email course on making your product team AI-native. Unsubscribe anytime.

The Guide

5 key steps synthesized from 14 experts.

1

Identify True Competitive Alternatives

List everything customers do today to solve the problem, including doing nothing. Focus on the status quo and hidden competitors like Excel to understand the real bar you must clear and what you are truly replacing.

Featured guest perspectives
"Positioning as a concept is not new; it defines how your product is the best in the world at delivering some value that a well-defined set of companies care a lot about."
— Lenny Rachitsky
"But in B2B we kind of have two sets of competitors. We have status quo, which is whatever the company is doing to attempt to solve the problem right now, even if it's crappy and not great. And then there's, if the company does decide they're going to buy something different, they usually make a short list. I need to be able to put a stake in the ground and say, I got to beat all that in order to win a deal."
— EOY Review
"I had the realization that the starting point had to be competitive alternatives. If it wasn’t, what we ended up with was positioning that sounded good in the office but didn’t work with customers because it wasn’t differentiated."
— Lenny Rachitsky
2

Isolate Unique Attributes and Value

Document the specific capabilities you have that the alternatives lack. Map these unique features directly to the differentiated value or the specific outcome the customer cares about to ensure the benefit is obvious.

Featured guest perspectives
"Positioning defines how your product is the best in the world, delivering some value that a well-defined set of companies care a lot about. So put another way, it encompasses a lot of things, it defines what are the alternatives to what you do? How are you different? What value can you deliver that no other product on the market can?"
— April Dunford
"Being different is not enough, because it's very easy to build a thing that's different from what exists today, because you just have to look at what exists today and build something else. Being better is not enough, because it's also easy to say, 'Hey, I'm going to make this thing better, and just charge you more money for it.' It has to be better than what exists today in a way that matters to the end user, and for us for a long time it was when someone says, 'Hey, why are you betting on Venmo?' I'd be like, 'Try and send me a dollar that I can use now,' and there was only one app you could do it with."
— Ayo Omojola
"The unique value that you can provide to customers is completely dependent on your differentiated features. Your differentiated features are only “differentiated” when you compare them to competitive alternatives."
— Lenny Rachitsky
3

Define Your Market Category

Choose a market category that sets the right expectations in the customer's mind. If you are a flexible horizontal tool, frame yourself as a familiar vertical solution to lower the cognitive burden for new users.

Featured guest perspectives
"If you use Notion, Notion are more understood as the productivity suite, but our intent, and if you use Notion, more you discover intent, which is that it has a no-code developer power into it and you can create almost any kind of productivity software using Notion itself."
— Ivan Zhao
"Positioning defines how your product is a leader at delivering something that a well-defined set of customers cares a lot about."
— Lenny Rachitsky
"So we prefer the term category design, and I can explain why design instead of creation, we don't have anything against creation, but creation creates a confusion in people's mind. When people hear category creation, because most people in business, most people in tech, are strongly oriented to product, what they think you said is first to ship a product that has X features."
— Christopher Lochhead
4

Frame the Strategic Narrative

Move beyond feature lists by identifying a fundamental shift in the customer's world. Position your product as the essential vehicle for winning in this new game while labeling competitors as relics of an obsolete old game.

Featured guest perspectives
"Every movie starts with some kind of shift in the world, and I call this shift the shift from the old game to a new game. The archetypal example of this, I think in the business world, is what Benioff did with Salesforce. This structure really is about defining a movement, and that's very different from, 'Hey, I'm going to solve your problem.'"
— Andy Raskin
"And what they did was instead of just saying, 'Hey, we're better than,' they said, 'Hey, all those others, those Siebel's, they're part of that old game. You want to play that software game? Be my guest, go buy Siebel,' and of course we know how it played out."
— Andy Raskin
"‘Safe’ marketing and positioning kills companies. ‘Consensus’ messaging created by committees is never any good. Be the forcing function to grow a backbone, stand for something, and make a splash in the market."
— Lenny Rachitsky
5

Distill the Remarkable Hook

Compress your value proposition into a single, punchy sentence that is bold enough to be remarkable. Avoid buzzwords and metaphors, focusing instead on a specific promise that forces people to pay attention.

Featured guest perspectives
"I remember my first day, I had an immediate reaction of like, ' We cannot make this thing Summit. That's not going to work. We can't have two brands. Summit's not ownable, we can't build equity and multiple things. That's just never going to work. We kind of have to just stick with one.'"
— Claire Butler

Get this guide as an AI skill for Claude Code

Includes our free 8-email course on making your product team AI-native. Unsubscribe anytime.

Install This Skill

Add this skill to Claude Code, Cursor, or any AI coding assistant that supports Agent Skills.

Quick Install (Recommended)

Install this skill directly using npx:

npx skills add RefoundAI/lenny-skills --skill positioning

Or install all 76 skills:

npx skills add RefoundAI/lenny-skills
View on GitHub →
Manual Installation
1

Download the skill

Download Skill (.zip)
2

Add to your project

Create a folder in your project root and add the skill file:

.claude/skills/positioning/SKILL.md
3

Start using it

Claude will automatically detect and use the skill when relevant. You can also invoke it directly:

Help me with strategic product positioning

Guest Perspectives

Deep dive into what 13 podcast guests shared about strategic product positioning.

Andy Raskin 2 quotes
Listen to episode →
"Every movie starts with some kind of shift in the world, and I call this shift the shift from the old game to a new game. The archetypal example of this, I think in the business world, is what Benioff did with Salesforce. This structure really is about defining a movement, and that's very different from, 'Hey, I'm going to solve your problem.'"
Tactical:
  • Start the pitch by identifying a fundamental shift in the customer's world.
  • Define the 'new game' and the rules required to win within it.
  • Position your product as the essential tool to help users navigate this new paradigm.
"And what they did was instead of just saying, 'Hey, we're better than,' they said, 'Hey, all those others, those Siebel's, they're part of that old game. You want to play that software game? Be my guest, go buy Siebel,' and of course we know how it played out."
Tactical:
  • Categorize competitors as representatives of an outdated paradigm or 'old game.'
  • Highlight the new market rules that your competitors are unable to satisfy.
  • Direct potential customers to incumbents only if they wish to continue playing by obsolete rules.
View all skills from Andy Raskin →
April Dunford 2 quotes
"Positioning defines how your product is the best in the world, delivering some value that a well-defined set of companies care a lot about. So put another way, it encompasses a lot of things, it defines what are the alternatives to what you do? How are you different? What value can you deliver that no other product on the market can?"
Tactical:
  • Identify the true competitive alternatives customers use today, including non-obvious ones like spreadsheets.
  • Define the specific value your product delivers that no other solution on the market can match.
  • Focus your strategy on a well-defined set of target companies that value your unique solution the most.
"So I think a lot of weak positioning comes from the fact that we don't have perfect alignment across the team on all these piece parts of positioning. So in the work I do, and even back when I was a VP marketing, if we're going to fix this thing, we can't just have the marketing department or just the product managers sit down and cook up new positioning and then heave it over the wall to everybody else, it actually needs to be a group effort."
Tactical:
  • Assemble a task force that includes leaders from marketing, product, sales, and customer success for positioning exercises.
  • Ensure the CEO and executive team are active participants to guarantee the new positioning sticks company-wide.
  • Avoid letting the marketing department develop positioning in a silo and 'heave it over the wall' to other teams.
View all skills from April Dunford →
Arielle Jackson 1 quote
"The positioning was really that it was for brick and mortar businesses, particularly quick serve coffee, donuts, sandwich shops that kind of quick serve brick and mortars. And it was up against your ugly old point of sale. Your cash register effectively. That was our foil."
Tactical:
  • Identify a specific competitor or outdated method to act as a 'foil' for your positioning.
  • Narrow your initial target audience to a very specific niche, like quick-serve coffee shops.
  • Clearly contrast your product's unified experience against the 'ugly' status quo.
View all skills from Arielle Jackson →
Ayo Omojola 1 quote
Listen to episode →
"Being different is not enough, because it's very easy to build a thing that's different from what exists today, because you just have to look at what exists today and build something else. Being better is not enough, because it's also easy to say, 'Hey, I'm going to make this thing better, and just charge you more money for it.' It has to be better than what exists today in a way that matters to the end user, and for us for a long time it was when someone says, 'Hey, why are you betting on Venmo?' I'd be like, 'Try and send me a dollar that I can use now,' and there was only one app you could do it with."
Tactical:
  • Identify a specific value vector—such as 'instant' availability—where your product is fundamentally superior to competitors.
  • Avoid building features that are merely different; ensure they solve a core problem in a way that matters to the end user.
  • Create a simple use-case comparison that clearly demonstrates your product's advantage over the market leader.
View all skills from Ayo Omojola →
Barbra Gago 1 quote
Listen to episode →
"When you're building a category, you need to make sure that there is a category that's validated by analysts and directory sites and things like that. But also, you want to have a lot of traction in terms of thought leadership like why is this the category? What are the unique value propositions of this particular thing? What are the pain points it solves?"
Tactical:
  • Validate your category through industry analysts and directory sites like G2 to establish market presence.
  • Produce thought leadership content that defines the unique value proposition and the specific pain points the category addresses.
  • Focus on educating buyers to help them transition from descriptive pain points to a formal budget allocation for the new category.
View all skills from Barbra Gago →
Christopher Lochhead 3 quotes
Listen to episode →
"In tech market categories, on average, one company earns two-thirds, 76% to be exact, of the total value created as measured by market cap and or valuation. So not market share, which is important, market cap as measured by the value of all the companies in the category. One company, two-thirds of the economics."
Tactical:
  • Aim to be the category leader to capture the approximately 76% of total value in the market.
  • Prioritize category design to define a new space rather than just building a better product in an old one.
  • Measure market leadership through total market cap dominance rather than just unit market share.
"The decision they make is, 'What I'm going to do, is I am going to compete in a market with demand, with a better product/service/brand, maybe a better business model, maybe a better set of growth hacking ideas that I learned on the Lenny Podcast. And when the world gets my better, the world will beat a path to my door.'"
Tactical:
  • Reject the 'better trap' where you try to out-feature incumbents in a pre-existing market.
  • Distinguish between 'creating demand' for a new category and 'capturing demand' in an existing one.
  • Avoid the unconsidered decision to compete in a crowded space where you can only fight for a fraction of the value.
"So we prefer the term category design, and I can explain why design instead of creation, we don't have anything against creation, but creation creates a confusion in people's mind. When people hear category creation, because most people in business, most people in tech, are strongly oriented to product, what they think you said is first to ship a product that has X features."
Tactical:
  • Use the specific term 'category design' to shift the focus from shipping features to market architecture.
  • Identify and replace words that trigger customers to compare your product with existing competitors.
  • Develop a strategic vocabulary that reinforces why your category is different, not just better.
View all skills from Christopher Lochhead →
Claire Butler 1 quote
Listen to episode →
"I remember my first day, I had an immediate reaction of like, ' We cannot make this thing Summit. That's not going to work. We can't have two brands. Summit's not ownable, we can't build equity and multiple things. That's just never going to work. We kind of have to just stick with one.'"
Tactical:
  • Choose a single, ownable brand name that logically clicks with the product's basic premise.
  • Avoid abstract metaphors and buzzwords that create friction or confusion for the user.
  • Consolidate brand equity into one name rather than splitting it across company and product identities.
View all skills from Claire Butler →
EOY Review 1 quote
"But in B2B we kind of have two sets of competitors. We have status quo, which is whatever the company is doing to attempt to solve the problem right now, even if it's crappy and not great. And then there's, if the company does decide they're going to buy something different, they usually make a short list. I need to be able to put a stake in the ground and say, I got to beat all that in order to win a deal."
Tactical:
  • Identify the status quo—what the company is doing right now—as a primary competitor.
  • Translate product features into distinct value themes to differentiate from the shortlist alternatives.
  • Define the characteristics of target accounts that will derive the most obvious value from your product.
View all skills from EOY Review →
Ivan Zhao 1 quote
Listen to episode →
"If you use Notion, Notion are more understood as the productivity suite, but our intent, and if you use Notion, more you discover intent, which is that it has a no-code developer power into it and you can create almost any kind of productivity software using Notion itself."
Tactical:
  • Market horizontal software as a familiar vertical solution like a 'productivity suite' for easy onboarding.
  • Empower users to build their own custom tools using simple, flexible building blocks.
  • Allow the product's deeper flexibility and intent to be discovered gradually over time.
View all skills from Ivan Zhao →
Jag Duggal 1 quote
Listen to episode →
"We're not trying to be incrementally better, we are trying to be fundamentally different. We want our customers to love us fanatically."
Tactical:
  • Use the Amazon 'mock press release' technique to articulate the value proposition before building.
  • Identify trade-off constraints in the industry and seek ways to break them.
  • Assess product reviews to ensure features redefine the category on dimensions like price and quality.
View all skills from Jag Duggal →
Krithika Shankarraman 2 quotes
Listen to episode →
"When you analyze your competitors' approaches, evaluating what others do in the space can kind of give you a useful baseline and identify opportunities and gaps and niches that your company can take in instead. And then, this is the critical step. The next one is you have to intentionally take a different path than what everyone else is doing."
Tactical:
  • Evaluate competitor strategies to establish a baseline of industry standards rather than a playbook to copy.
  • Look for marketing inspiration in domains far outside your vertical to find creative tactics you can cross-apply.
  • Intentionally drive a strategy that sets you apart from competitors to avoid getting stuck in industry-standard local maxima.
"If you can think of it as sort of a three-legged race from the very beginning of product development, then you go to market with the right thing in the first place. You get these insights from customers, you hear the language that they're using, which can be the sort of cheat code for how to message and position the product in market."
Tactical:
  • Embed product marketing with the product team from the start of development to capture the authentic language of users.
  • Focus on creating use-case epiphanies that show technical users exactly how a product solves a specific problem in their lives.
  • Reject vanity metrics like clicks and impressions in favor of measuring the specific experience you want customers to have with the brand.
View all skills from Krithika Shankarraman →
Laura Modi 1 quote
Listen to episode →
"And my desire was to create a formula that parents could feel proud of, an infant formula that felt modern and met where science is today. Because frankly, none of the infant formulas on the market really had caught up to where science has evolved to."
Tactical:
  • Identify industries where consumer products haven't evolved alongside current science.
  • Build brand identity around making the customer feel proud of their choice.
  • Target industries controlled by duopolies that have neglected modern user values.
View all skills from Laura Modi →
Lulu Cheng Meservey 2 quotes
Listen to episode →
"So it's a huge lift to try to change someone's worldview or their passions. It's a light lift to take the thing you want to talk about and just shape it into, to fit into their worldview or their passions."
Tactical:
  • Identify your audience's "cultural erogenous zones" to understand their existing passions.
  • Shape your product's story to fit within the audience's established worldview.
  • Create a conceptual "API" or bridge that connects the user's interests directly to your offering.
"And so a few things that you can do with an idea to make it spread better, you can make it into a joke, so you can turn it into a line that people will repeat. You can use an analogy, you can take something and just say it over and over, move fast and break things, don't be evil, build something people want."
Tactical:
  • Package the core idea into a joke or a short, rhythmic phrase that is easy to repeat.
  • Use vivid analogies or colorful mental images that recipients can visualize immediately.
  • Replace subjective adjectives with concrete anecdotes that people can retell in conversation.
View all skills from Lulu Cheng Meservey →